Skip to content
Snippets Groups Projects
Commit 73f1a103 authored by Gregory Szorc's avatar Gregory Szorc
Browse files

packaging: use PyOxidizer for producing WiX MSI installer

We recently taught our in-tree PyOxidizer configuration file to
produce MSI installers with WiX using PyOxidizer's built-in
support for doing so.

This commit changes our WiX + PyOxidizer installer generation
code to use this functionality.

After this change, all the Python packaging code is doing is the
following:

* Building HTML documentation
* Making gettext available to the build process.
* Munging CLI arguments to variables for the `pyoxidizer` execution.
* Invoking `pyoxidizer build`.
* Copying the produced `.msi` to the `dist/` directory.

Applying this stack on stable and rebuilding the 5.8 MSI installer
produced the following differences from the official 5.8 installer:

* .exe and .pyd files aren't byte identical (this is expected).
* Various .dist-info/ directories have different names due to older
  versions of PyOxidizer being buggy and not properly normalizing
  package names. (The new behavior is correct.)
* Various *.dist-info/RECORD files are different due to content
  divergence of files (this is expected).
* The python38.dll differs due to newer PyOxidizer shipping a newer
  version of Python 3.8.
* We now ship python3.dll because PyOxidizer now includes this file
  by default.
* The vcruntime140.dll differs because newer PyOxidizer installs a newer
  version. We also now ship a vcruntime140_1.dll because newer versions
  of the redistributable ship 2 files now.

The WiX GUIDs and IDs of installed files have likely changed as a
result of PyOxidizer's different mechanism for generating those
identifiers. This means that an upgrade install of the MSI will
replace files instead of doing an incremental update. This is
likely harmless and we've incurred this kind of breakage before.

As far as I can tell, the new PyOxidizer-built MSI is functionally
equivalent to the old method. Once we drop support for Python 2.7
MSI installers, we can delete the WiX code from the repository.

This commit temporarily drops support for extra `.wxs` files. We
raise an exception instead of silently not using them, which I think
is appropriate. We should be able to add support back in by injecting
state into pyoxidizer.bzl via `--var`. I just didn't want to expend
cognitive load to think about the solution as part of this series.

Differential Revision: https://phab.mercurial-scm.org/D10688
parent d09b36f6
No related branches found
No related tags found
No related merge requests found
Loading
0% Loading or .
You are about to add 0 people to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Please register or to comment